Ranking NHL's Phase 2 Draft Lottery Teams By Worthiness

Minnesota Wild

Create a free account to unlock this article!

Get Started

Already a subscriber?  Log In

The end of the qualifying round marks Phase 2 of the NHL’s altered draft lottery set for 6 PM EST, Monday evening, where eight teams will be thrown into an even chance at the No. 1 pick in 2020.

Phase 2 comes after the first phase saw a placeholder team win the No. 1 pick in 2020, which was set to be one of the eight losing teams in the qualifying round of the 24-team expanded playoffs.

The end of the qualifying round means the New York Rangers, Edmonton Oilers, Pittsburgh Penguins, Minnesota Wild, Winnipeg Jets, Nashville Predators, Florida Panthers, and Toronto Maple Leafs will each earn an even 12.5 percent chance at the No. 1 pick, or consensus top player, Alexis Lafrenière.

But the aforementioned altered draft lottery procedure — due to COVID-19 and the lack of a full 82-game regular season — is rewarding mediocre teams while neglecting the worst teams of 2019-20.

That means the eight teams involved each had realistic expectations at the 2020 NHL postseason, prior to the season cancellation. Moreover, those teams hold different levels of worthiness when it comes to their 12.5 percent chance at the coveted No. 1 pick.

1. Minnesota Wild

Last No. 1 Pick: Never (since 2000)

The Wild have had fluctuating success in 20 NHL seasons and while they’ve viewed themselves as Stanley Cup contenders in past seasons, they’ve always been an underdog with better (and arguably more-deserving teams) around them.

A surprise run in 2019-20 kept them relevant in the playoff fight before being exposed by Vancouver for a lack of real contention. Now, with no game-breaking talent, the Wild are at a crossroads for the future: stuck between riding out the twilight years of the core versus rebuilding it for the future.

2. Nashville Predators

Last No. 1 Pick: Never (since 1998)

GM David Poile has done everything right: making trades, taking risks, fair contracts, etc., but has yet to be fully rewarded. It’s not easy to say the 2017 runners-up deserve the No. 1 pick just three years later, but there are less-deserving teams.

Since that final loss in 2017, the Predators have taken a step back in the playoffs each season and clearly lack a true game-changing talent on the offense, despite good forwards. Having never had the No. 1 pick in 22 seasons, Lafrenière is a justifiable answer for Poile and the Preds. 

3. New York Rangers

Last No. 1 Pick: Andre Veilleux, 1965

Sure, the Rangers haven’t had the first overall pick since 1965, but they still have some of the best young talent in the NHL and are looking extremely dangerous in the near future.

A Hart Trophy nominee in Artemi Panarin is surrounded by younger, blossoming stars that would be capped off with Lafrenière. Management has done the rebuild right and made smart moves and given the lottery teams around them, are among the most deserving of Lafrenière.

4. Florida Panthers

Last No. 1 Pick: Aaron Ekblad, 2014

The Panthers are loaded with good young players and have tried hard to build a winning program. Still, there is something seemingly holding them back form regular playoff success.

Lafrenière might not be the real answer; attempting to outscore weaknesses has never been a proven recipe for winning. Still, landing the winger would help alleviate cap problems with an entry-level deal for a surefire roster player. But this team needs more than added offense.

5. Winnipeg Jets

Last No. 1 Pick: Ilya Kovalchuk, 2001 (as Atlanta Thrashers) 

The Jets faced a plethora of injuries in the qualifying round, including top-line center Mark Scheifele just five minutes into the series and top-line winger Patrik Laine at the end of Game 1.

While injuries held them back, they remain a dangerous offensive team that had to patchwork a defense due to various reasons shortly before 2019-20. Defense is the concern, and similarly to Florida, landing Lafrenière could create too much reliance on attempting to outscore deficiencies.

6. Toronto Maple Leafs

Last No. 1 Pick: Auston Matthews, 2016

Since landing Matthews in 2016, the Leafs have been a perennial playoff contender, despite a lack of postseason success. Alongside Matthews are top picks Mitch Marner, William Nylander, Morgan Reilly, and former No. 1 pick John Tavares, signed via free agency.

Lafrenière would be too easy of an answer for a team facing defensive problems and a salary cap nightmare. Further, giving GM Kyle Dubas the chance at Lafrenière would make a money-based trade too easy and reward him for mediocrity with elite talent.

7. Edmonton Oilers

Last No. 1 Pick: Connor McDavid, 2015

Similar to the Leafs, the Oilers have been handed far too many opportunities to return to regular Stanley Cup hopes after receiving the No. 1 pick in 2011, 2012, 2013, and 2015 (Taylor Hall, Nail Yakupov, Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, and McDavid).

Ignoring the choice to move on form Hall and Yakupov, and adding in reigning NHL leading-scorer Leon Draisaitl, the Oilers don’t deserve another top tier player without developing him first. Giving two of the top NHL players a young prodigy is sure to spark outrage from the fans. 

8. Pittsburgh Penguins

Last No. 1 Pick: Sidney Crosby, 2005

Since drafting Crosby in 2005, the Penguins have claimed three Stanley Cups (2009, 2016, and 2017) and cemented the franchise as one of the best in the salary cap era. This amount of success does not warrant a No. 1 pick after a mere season of missing the playoffs.

Even with Crosby and teammate Evgeni Malkin at the ages of 33 and 34, respectively, the duo has continued to produce at a prime level offensively and rewarding the team with Lafrenière would certainly draw criticism and anger from hockey fans that watched the Penguins succeed annually. 


Have a question or a comment for Jacob Messing? You can find him on Twitter @Jacob_Messing.

NCAA To ECHL: Rookies To Watch In 2020-21

Gordi Myer

Last month, the ECHL announced a revised start date to their upcoming season, slating Dec. 4 as opening night for the 2020-21 campaign.

Create a free account to unlock this article!

Get Started

Already a subscriber?  Log In

WCHA Men's & Women's Hockey To Delay Start Of 2020-21 Season

Michigan Tech Athletics

BLOOMINGTON, Minn. – Sept. 10, 2020 – The Men’s League of the Western Collegiate Hockey Association will delay the start of its 2020-21 season, WCHA Men’s League Commissioner Bill Robertson announced today.

Experience Is Paying Off For The Tampa Bay Lightning

Tampa Bay Lightning

The Tampa Bay Lightning have been a perennial Stanley Cup contender for the better half of the last decade, but 2020 may finally be their year.

Create a free account to unlock this article!

Get Started

Already a subscriber?  Log In

Atlantic Hockey Juggles Complicated Return-To-Play Protocol

Army coach

In March of 2020, with conference tournaments underway and the national tournament right around the corner, college hockey was canceled as we knew it. Nobody knew for how long, or what each circumstance would lead to. Now, many months later, as college campuses begin to return and athletes look towards their seasons, it seems as though times around the country are becoming more and more unprecedented. With 11 institutions making up Atlantic Hockey, each with different return-to-campus procedures, many different plans have been formulated by leaders within the conference. 

NCAA Round-Up: Where Do Conferences Stand With Returning To Play?

Kelly Shea / AIC

As COVID-19 continues to create uncertainty around the world, the 2020-21 NCAA hockey season is just another piece of the puzzle left in disarray. 

An NCAA-Built Blue Line Is Helping The Rangers Reforge Their Franchise

Adam Fox, Ryan Lindgren, New York Rangers

The draft lottery-winning New York Rangers are poised to select consensus No. 1 pick Alexis Lafrenière in the 2020 NHL draft as another core piece to an impressive rebuild and budding powerhouse.

Create a free account to unlock this article!

Get Started

Already a subscriber?  Log In

6 Takeaways From NHL's Re-Opening Weekend

Connor Hellebuyck, Winnipeg Jets

Saturday marked the first official NHL games since mid-March and the (re)opening weekend of the NHL was full of excitement, highlights, and lots of nail-biting.

Create a free account to unlock this article!

Get Started

Already a subscriber?  Log In

Detroit Red Wings Using The NCAA To Develop Prospects

Yzerman and the Red Wings

The Detroit Red Wings have suffered a steady decline in winning percentage over the past four seasons, ultimately leading to a last-place finish among all 31 teams in 2019-20.

Create a free account to unlock this article!

Get Started

Already a subscriber?  Log In

NHL Trade Deadline Deals Recap: Carolina Adds Firepower & Much More

Sami Vatanen, Carolina Hurricanes

With the continuation of the NHL season less than two weeks away, enough has occurred in the near five-month hiatus to forget about those who will be rejoining their new teams for a chance to win the Stanley Cup.

Create a free account to unlock this article!

Get Started

Already a subscriber?  Log In